ARBIMETRA · Financial intelligence, made practical.

Investment Security Analysis and Valuation

Fundamental Analysis vs Technical Analysis

How fundamental analysis values a business from its financials and economy, how technical analysis reads price charts and indicators, and what evidence says about each.

Beginner5 min readUpdated Published

Share

Investors trying to decide what to buy and when tend to follow one of two broad approaches. Fundamental analysis asks what a company is really worth, based on its business, financial statements and the economy. Technical analysis studies price and trading volume history to identify trends and patterns that might indicate future price movements. Many investors combine elements of both; understanding their logic and limits helps you judge any investment recommendation.

What you will learn

  • Describe the steps and tools of fundamental analysis
  • Explain the main ideas and indicators of technical analysis
  • Calculate a simple moving average and interpret a crossover
  • Evaluate both approaches in light of market efficiency

Fundamental analysis

Fundamental analysis estimates a security’s intrinsic value and compares it with the market price. It is usually done in three layers — the "top-down" approach:

  1. Economy: growth, inflation, interest rates and exchange rates affect all companies — see economic indicators.
  2. Industry: demand trends, competition, regulation and the industry’s stage of development.
  3. Company: business model, competitive advantages, management quality, and financial performance.

The company layer draws on financial statement analysis: revenue and profit growth, margins, return on equity, debt levels, cash flow and earnings quality. The analyst then estimates value using models such as the dividend discount model, P/E multiples or DCF.

Worked example: a fundamental comparison

Two companies in the same industry each trade at 120 per share (illustrative figures):

Company ACompany B
Earnings per share10.06.0
P/E ratio12.020.0
Expected earnings growth4%18%
Return on equity11%24%
Debt to equity1.60.4

Company A looks cheaper on P/E, but Company B grows faster, earns higher returns on equity and has much less debt. A fundamental analyst would ask whether B’s higher P/E is justified by its growth and quality — the PEG ratio (P/E ÷ growth) is 3.0 for A and about 1.1 for B. Calculate P/E for real companies with the P/E calculator.

Graham’s The Intelligent Investor remains a classic statement of the fundamental approach: buy businesses for less than they are worth, with a margin of safety.

Technical analysis

Technical analysis rests on three ideas (Murphy describes them as its premises): market prices reflect available information; prices move in trends; and patterns of investor behaviour tend to repeat. Technical analysts study charts rather than financial statements.

Common tools:

ToolWhat it shows
Trend linesThe direction of price movements — rising, falling or sideways
Support and resistancePrice levels where buying or selling has repeatedly appeared
Moving averagesSmoothed price trends; crossovers used as signals
Relative Strength Index (RSI)Momentum on a 0–100 scale; above 70 often called "overbought", below 30 "oversold"
MACDThe relationship between two moving averages, used to spot momentum changes
VolumeConfirms the strength of price moves
Chart patternsShapes such as "head and shoulders" or triangles

Worked example: a simple moving average

A share’s closing prices over ten days were 100, 102, 101, 105, 107, 106, 110, 108, 112 and 115 (illustrative figures). The 5-day simple moving average (SMA) is the average of the latest five closes:

DayClose5-day SMA
5107103.0
6106104.2
7110105.8
8108107.2
9112108.6
10115110.2

The price stays above a rising moving average, which a technical analyst would read as an uptrend. A fall of the price below the average — or a shorter average crossing below a longer one — might be read as a warning signal.

Closing price and 5-day moving average

Line chart for days 5 to 10: the closing price moves from 107 to 115 with small dips, while the 5-day moving average rises smoothly from 103.0 to 110.2, staying below the price.0.050.0100.0150.0Day 5Day 6Day 7Day 8Day 9Day 10
Illustrative figures for explanation only — not real market or company data.
Show the data
Close5-day SMA
Day 5107.0103.0
Day 6106.0104.2
Day 7110.0105.8
Day 8108.0107.2
Day 9112.0108.6
Day 10115.0110.2

Comparing the two approaches

Fundamental analysisTechnical analysis
Key questionWhat is it worth?Where is the price likely to go next?
DataFinancial statements, economy, industryPrices, volume, indicators
Time horizonUsually months to yearsOften days to months
Main usersLong-term investors, analysts, lendersTraders, short-term investors
Main weaknessForecasts and valuations can be wrong; mispricing may persistPatterns may be chance; signals often fail after costs

What the evidence says

The efficient market hypothesis (Fama, 1970) argues that if markets quickly reflect information, neither approach should consistently produce above-average returns after costs. In its weak form, past prices cannot predict future prices — directly challenging technical analysis. In its semi-strong form, public information such as financial statements is already in prices — challenging fundamental analysis based only on public data.

Research has found some exceptions, such as momentum (recent winners tending to keep outperforming for a time) and value effects, but many apparent patterns disappear after costs or once they become widely known. Most professional fund managers do not outperform their benchmarks consistently after fees. Behavioural biases — see behavioural finance — offer one explanation for patterns that do persist.

For most individual investors, the practical lessons are: use fundamental analysis to avoid overpaying for poor businesses, be sceptical of trading signals, and keep costs low.

Common mistakes

  • Judging a share as cheap or expensive from one ratio.
  • Trading on chart patterns without testing them or counting costs.
  • Ignoring the economic and industry context.
  • Confusing a good company with a good investment at any price.
  • Trading too frequently — see behavioural finance on overconfidence.

Key terms

  • Fundamental analysis — estimating intrinsic value from business and economic information.
  • Technical analysis — forecasting prices from past price and volume data.
  • Moving average — an average of prices over a rolling window.
  • Support and resistance — price levels where buying or selling has tended to appear.
  • Momentum — the tendency of recent price trends to continue for a time.

Frequently asked questions

Can I combine fundamental and technical analysis?

Yes. Some investors choose what to buy with fundamentals and use technical signals to time entries and exits.

Does technical analysis work?

Evidence is mixed. Some effects such as momentum have been documented, but many signals fail after transaction costs.

Do I need to analyse individual shares to invest?

No. Diversified index funds let you invest without selecting individual securities.

Key takeaways

  • Fundamental analysis values a business from the economy, industry and company financials.
  • Technical analysis looks for trends and patterns in price and volume.
  • Market efficiency means neither approach reliably beats the market after costs.
  • Use analysis to avoid mistakes and overpaying, and keep trading costs low.